
In this column, I provide Google 'Overviews' on my activism - my methods and some of the issues which have called for activism. These Overviews provide background information which supplements the far more extensive information I provide on the Home Page of the site and other pages of the site. This page is taking up time which would be more constructively spent on activities such as documentation and prototyping for my United States patent application, other design and construction work, the many other activities which are shown on the Home Page and other pages of the site. I need to reduce my time on such issues as the continuing allegations of South Yorkshire Police North West and the Green Party. For years, far too long, I've had to contend with the time-wasting antics of South Yorkshire Police and the Church Army. Now that the Church Army seems to have stopped its astonishing - and astonishingly unjust - attacks, the Green Party has taken onthe role of the organization which South Yorkshire Police North West would like to use as an attempt at suppression. Claims of suppression, like claims of oppression, can be fully justified or completely unjustified. In this site, I present the evidence that false allegations have been used repeatedly, that my views aren't in the least unjustified - but the cost in time which would have been better spent on other matters has to be taken into account.
A reminder that these Overviews were not written by me but provided by Google. A further reminder that I don't myself make use of AI, except for the quotations and extracts of Overviews provided here and on the Home Page.
Before the Overviews, some pages of the site with much more detailed information:
https://linkagenet.com/themes/south-yorkshire-police.htm
South Yorkshire Police: a knock at the door
https://linkagenet.com/themes/south-yorkshire-police-mayor.htm
https://linkagenet.com/themes/complaints-syp-pcc.htm
Alan
Billings South Yorkshire Police and Crime Commissioner
Overview (1)
On his personal website, Paul Hurt’s Linkage Site, the author and independent commentator compiles extensive critiques focused on modern activism, ideology, and institutional corruption. His core methodology emphasizes "argument and evidence," arguing that most contemporary political and social movements distort reality to serve dogmatic beliefs. [Correction: I don't claim that 'most' political and social movements distort reality to serve dogmatic beliefs.]
1. Activism and "Argument Evidence"
Hurt rejects mainstream, disruptive protest methods—such as demonstrations, vigils, or student encampments—as performative and ineffective. He believes traditional protests only bring temporary attention without creating systemic change.
Instead, he advocates for:
Direct Pressure: Targeting campaigns specifically toward individuals or institutions who hold the actual legislative or economic power to enact change.
Documented Evidence: Using local, on-the-ground documentation (such as his own photography and written analysis of local events in Sheffield, England) to substantiate claims.
Independence: Maintaining strict distance from established institutions, economic interests, and religions to prevent the compromise of his core arguments
Overview
(2)
'Appreciation-protest' and 'admiration-criticism.'
The string of keywords refers directly to the philosophy and personal
writings of writer and thinker
Paul Hurt,
who documents his specific frameworks on his personal
website,
Linkage.a
Hurt uses the unique paired concepts of "appreciation-criticism" and "admiration-criticism" to analyze public institutions, specifically documenting his complex interactions and official complaints against South Yorkshire Police (SYP).
Core Concepts Explained
Appreciation-Criticism & Admiration-Criticism: These are self-coined terms used by Paul Hurt to describe a balanced, non-destructive form of accountability. He argues that a person can fiercely criticize an organization's errors or misuse of resources while maintaining deep admiration and appreciation for its underlying necessity and the difficult job its workers perform. On his homepage, he notes that his strict critiques of South Yorkshire Police fall entirely into these categories because he believes the force's structural benefits to society vastly outweigh the harm of its individual missteps.
The South Yorkshire Police Grievances: Hurt’s writings detail personal case studies regarding police accountability, including:
An official complaint submitted to the Professional Standards Department of SYP against a Sergeant over what Hurt deemed a flagrant "misuse of police resources" regarding priorities and time management.
Overview 3
The need to scrutinize the statements and actions of South Yorkshire Police very carefully, the need to hold South Yorkshire Police to account.
Extract from the page
2 December, 2025
'The Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) has today (2 December 2025) published its report into the mishandling of the Hillsborough disaster in 1989, at which 97 Liverpool Football Club supporters were unlawfully killed.
'The IOPC’s report stated that 12 police officers would have faced gross misconduct cases over Hillsborough if they were still serving, but none will face disciplinary proceedings because they have all retired. Since 2017, police misconduct cases take place even if an officer has resigned.
'Speaking to Naga Munchetty on BBC Radio 5 Live earlier today (2:45:50), Garden Court North’s Pete Weatherby KC, who represented 22 of the Hillsborough families at the fresh inquests, said: “The best that can be said of [the report] is that it’s further vindication of what we knew already”.
'“The police promulgated a false narrative that the disaster was caused by late, drunk, ticketless fans – those are the three pillars of what was an industrial-scale cover-up”, Pete continued. “For the Head of the IOPC to not call it a cover-up, I find very surprising indeed, because through the Hillsborough Independent Panel and two years’ of inquest evidence, all three of those pillars of false narrative were completely taken apart. There was undoubtedly a cover-up. South Yorkshire Police themselves have accepted that senior officers told lies in the aftermath of the disaster.”
'Ten of the officers who would have faced gross misconduct cases were in the South Yorkshire Police. The report identifies six gross misconduct allegations against Peter Wright, then Chief Constable, including his attempts to minimise the SYP’s responsibility and deflect blame on to the victims.
'The 366-page report was delivered to bereaved families in recent days. The IOPC has spent 13 years compiling the report, describing it as “the largest independent investigation into alleged police misconduct and criminality ever carried out in England and Wales”.
'The IOPC said in the report that it had found 110 complaints upheld or cases to answer against former officers, including for “falsehood and prevarication”, “discreditable conduct”, “abuse of authority” and “neglect of duty”.'








The day after Eamonn Ward informed me that he had sent a copy of my email to South Yorkshire Police, I received a phone call from SYP, in the person of Inspector Nik Dodsworth of Sheffield North West Division. He reminded me that we had already had a phone conversation (quite a long time ago.) I was already aware of that. He had made a request which I felt was impermissible, not one that I could possibly accept. On this occasion, he was phoning about recent events, the completely misguided action of Eamonn Ward.
It occurred to me: why would someone of the rank of Inspector be phoning me about such a matter? A sergeant would be the expected agent for this futile mission. What is going on here? Perhaps the police do view the matter as serious. Perhaps the Green Party is in a state of some panic, meeting determined, evidence-based opposition they had never expected. Perhaps Eamonn Ward was acting alone, attempting to suppress reasonable and courteous communication (and not for the first time.) The phone call was at an inconvenient time. I cut it short.
The Electoral Commission doesn't disapprove of anonymous denunciations, or not in every case ...
... such as the claim made by a South Yorkshire Police Inspector, Nik Dodsworth of the North West Division that a 'Green Party councillor (not named) has allegedly suffered 'upset and distress' and that I'm responsible. His vague smear is completely irresponsible. It's unaccompanied by any record of words and / or actions of mine - alleged words / actions of mine. I need to find out the identity of this mysterious Green Party councillor. In the meantime, as some light relief, I provide below information, with images, about provision for denunciations centuries ago, in Venice. We now have the benefit of technologically advanced communications - but the content of an email can be ridiculous, stupid and backward. Almost certainly, the denunciation reached South Yorkshire Police by email.
Another email whose content is miserably lacking in sophistication.
The Electoral Commission. Email sent to me, 4 November, 2026:
Dear Paul,
Thank you for contacting the Electoral Commission a few weeks ago. Please accept our apologies for the delayed response.
Our role in campaigning
The Commission does not regulate individual campaigns or the content of campaign materials. However, we encourage all campaigners to fulfil their important role responsibly and promote transparency.
Certain election campaign materials published by particular people or organisations must identify who is responsible for their publication. This information is called an imprint. As you are not a relevant entity, you do not need to include an imprint on your campaign materials.
Contact with South Yorkshire Police
South Yorkshire Police have confirmed that Inspector Dodsworth advised you not to contact a Green Party councillor again because your contact was causing the councillor upset and distress. For future non-emergency enquiries, you can call 111 and ask for your enquiry to be referred to the force’s SPOC for elections. Each police force has a dedicated Single Point of Contact (SPOC) Officer who can offer advice.
Other than imprint requirements, individual campaigns and their content fall outside our remit, so we cannot advise further on this matter.
Kind regards,
[Name of the sender withheld for a very good reason: the named person who sent it is very unlikely to be the person or persons who decided what form the response should take. I've no wish to cause problems for the person who signed.
Email from me to the Electoral Commission, 4 November 2026
How denunciations were handled centuries ago, in Venice. The denunciations which were received by Inspector Dodsworth of South Yorkshire Police North West were almost certainly sent by email. Presumably, he knows the identity of the Green Party Councillor - or perhaps he doesn't have a specific Councillor who made these allegations. I've spoken to not a single Green Party Councillor this year or at any other time .There's material on a some Councillors on this Website but all of it is legitimate comment. None of it bears any relationship with the claim that I've inflicted upset and distress. Inspector Dodsworth has some explaining to do. He's made allegations but I have no knowledge of the person who made the allegations. Did anyone make the allegations? From my perspective, these are anonymous denunciations. This is how anonymous denunciations were brought to the attention of the authorities in pre-email Venice.


Above, two examples of the 'bocca di leone' (lion's mouth) in Venice. These were introduced after an attempt at a coup in 1310 and were managed by the 'Council of Ten' to receive information about a wide range of matters, including crime. Venetian citizens could insert notes through the slot, the open mouth of the lion. They are often described as methods used for anonymous denunciations but generally, anonymous notes were burned. False accusations could lead to severe punishment for accusers. The Lion of Venice is a bronze sculpture of a winged lion in Venice which symbolizes Venice and St Mark, one of its patron saints.
It seems that this Venetian custom was in advance of some South Yorkshire Police practices, where anonymous denunciations based on no evidence at all and other denunciations based on no evidence at all have been freely permitted, with no sanctions at all for false accusers.
What we have in Sheffield, at least in my experience, could be described as a free-for-all, in one restricted, figurative sense: 'operating without standard regulations or oversight.' Whatever regulations exist, they have been ignored. There has been no oversight.
When the Green Party has made ridiculous and completely false claims to South Yorkshire Police, the force has been happy to oblige and has attempted to suppress legitimate comment. When the Church Army has made ridiculous and completely false claims to the police, the police have made no attempt to find out what I have to say. They have gone ahead and done all they can to suppress legitimate comment.
A much more extensive discussion is needed to do justice to these multiple injustices and acts of stupidity - and I've provided the evidence in detail, on the Home Page of the site and other pages. South Yorkshire Police have acted irresponsibly, recklessly, unchecked by any effective oversight, such as the oversight of the Chief Constable or the Mayor, who also has responsibilities for oversight.

Above, South Yorkshire Police Headquarters, Snig Hill, Sheffield
Important Note: Although I mention some very critical comments on South Yorkshire Police, my own adverse - very adverse - experiences, recorded on the Home Page of the site and on this page are confined almost entirely to South Yorkshire Police North West Division, headed by Inspector Nik Dodsworth. In places where South Yorkshire Police is criticized without the qualification 'North West,' almost always the reference will be to the North West Division only - and not to all the police and other people working for North West Division but only a few, named here and on the Home Page. In the column to the left, there are extracts from Google Overviews which explain some aspects of my approach to campaigning and activism.I make every effort to make the criticism fair-minded, with recognition of the fact that people and organizations are very often only at fault in certain respects, with recognition of the need to avoid generalizations when generalizations aren't justified by the evidence. The Google Overviews outline amongst other things my 'appreciation-criticism' and 'admiration-criticism,' which apply to South Yorkshire Police (including Sheffield North West Division) but not to the Green Party, including Sheffield Green Party.
I went to South Yorkshire Police Headquarters, Snig Hill, shown above, three times over an extended period, in connection with my opposition to the grotesque actions of some named people at Sheffield North West Police - in opposition to the flagrant waste of time police by the police themselves, those same people. On two of the occasions, I found the staff excellent. On one of the occasions, the experience was a grotesque waste of time. In connection with one incident, which clearly showed that the police staff from Sheffield North West who were involved had no notion of the law of the land applicable or had decided to ignore it completely, I mentioned freedom of expression. The response of this member of staff at the police station was this. 'Freedom of expression? What does freedom of expression have to do with the police?'
In some parts of this page, I'll emphasize the importance of 'Oversight.' I think that Inspector Dodsworth has failed in matters to do with oversight and so has the Chief Constable, Laurel Pourtney, and so has the Mayor of South Yorkshire, Oliver Coppard. Obviously, none of these people will ever say, 'Oversight of the police? What's that got to do with me?' But I take the view that they have failed comprehensively - but not in all areas, only some. Oliver Coppard replaced Alan Billing, the dire, the abysmal Police and Crime Commissioner, a post which will be abolished when the existing commissioners come to the end of their terms of office. The experiment has not been a success.
Existing material on the Home Page and other pages on some grotesque blunders of South Yorkshire Police - but these amount to a large number of blunders, not a few - have been concerned almost entirely with the gross mistakes of people who are not high-ranking, Sergeant Simon Kirkham, Sergeant Hannah Woods, PC Sarah Forsythe, but in the page 'Losing the Plot,' the emphasis will be on the issue of oversight, responsibilities of
South Yorkshire Police functionaries and a few others who have much greater responsibilities - although they may ignore them to an extent or be largely indifferent to them or try to evade them. So, the emphasis will be upon such people as Inspector Nik Dodsworth, who supposedly has oversight responsibilities for the North West Division of South Yorkshire Police.
All the many problems I've experienced with South Yorkshire Police, all the falsifications, all the action which pays absolutely no attention to British law, which ignores elementary safeguards, all the failures to respond to courteous questions, the whole stupid mess, has to do with the North-West Division, but not all of it but only some of it.
I've absolutely no criticisms to make of other branches of the force, with some significant exceptions. In my experience, the Professional Standards Department of South Yorkshire Police is unfit for purpose (on the site, I outline the bizarre actions of an employee called simply 'Lauren' (she has ignored all requests to give her full name) and the Data Department holds data which is in a shambolic state - at least the data I've seen relating to me is shambolic - evidence of wider failings, perhaps. After a request to view the South Yorkshire Police data on me - not all of it, of course, I was sent a fairly short, redacted extract which was unbelievable in its disorder and uselessness. I was struck by an isolated remark amongst so much date detritus, a remark which was given no context, with absolutely no evidence. The allegation that 'Hurt is an extremist.'
Sergeant Kirkham left the North West Division to take up a position with the Barnsley police. I can easily show - I do show - that his failures are very severe. He does nothing to enhance the reputation of South Yorkshire Police. A force which valued its reputation should find a way to dispense with his services. Other pages of the site have to be consulted to obtain further information about this figure, and the other people, and there's a great deal of information.
So far, the people with the most important responsibilities for Oversight - which includes the responsibility to ensure that South Yorkshire actions are in accordance with the law of the land rather than blatantly ignoring them - have received no more than bare mentions on the site. I'm referring to the Mayor of South Yorkshire, Oliver Coppard, the Chief Constable, Lauren Poultney and Inspector Dodsworth, who has been ignoring some tiresome restrictions which are necessary for the continuance of fair-minded and unbianced policing, increasingly under threat well beyond Sheffield North West. I intend to rectify this imbalance. Attention to detail can surely be expected of these very well paid functionaries. I think - I'm certain - that the details I provide on this site in connection with South Yorkshire Police are significant details.
An email sent to Eamonn Ward, the Electoral Agent of Sheffield Green Party, 6 November 2026, giving extracts from two emails sent to the Electoral Commission on the same day. I don't supply here the reasons which led me to contact the Electoral Commission. The extracts can serve as an indirect but very useful introduction to the antics of Inspector Dodsworth and some of his subordinates, the people mentioned in the Home Page and in some other places.
To Eamonn Ward -
I provide these extracts from emails I sent today to the Electoral Commission because they have direct relevance to your practice and to your work as an election agent.
I have received your email of 4 November 2026. I find it a disturbing one. The member of South Yorkshire Police mentioned in your email, Inspector Nik Dodsworth, and certain members of the North West Division of South Yorkshire Police over whom he has oversight, have engaged in reckless allegations and reckless acts which are the subject of detailed scrutiny, with abundant evidence, on my Website. www.linkagenet.com He himself, and the members over whom he has oversight, have used vague smears based on complaints which I can show - and have shown - are fallacious and malicious. Never at any time has any evidence been produced which quote words of my own, in any medium (but not on Social Media - I never use Social Media and have never contributed anything to any Social Media platform.) This is the case with his most recent allegation, which was new to me: a complete lack of anything specific.
You write,
'Inspector Dodsworth advised you not to contact a Green Party
Councillor again because your contact was causing the councillor
'upset and distress.' This is a vague smear, unsupported by any
details. In fact, Inspector Dodsworth did phone me not long ago,
but gave no reason as to why he was phoning me. We were on the phone
for a few seconds only, because I said that I could not talk to him.
This wasn't an opportune moment for me to talk - I had demands on my
time - but more importantly, he has phoned me in the past and made
demands I consider outrageous. I insist that any communications with
him should be in written form only, so that I have documented
evidence. A phone call does not provide this documentation.
Not only did he not explain why he was phoning me, he did not at any time mention a Green Party Councillor. I'm contacting Inspector Dodsworth - naturally in writing - to request an answer to these reasonable questions. What was the name of the Councillor who claims to have experienced 'upset and distress?' What words of mine or acts of mine do you allege caused this upset and distress? I have had absolutely no communications with any Green Party councillors which could possibly be interpreted in those terms.
You also write, ' ... we
encourage all campaigners to fulfil their important role responsibly
and promote transparency.' This is outrageous. It seems that you
consider that I have not campaigned responsibly. What evidence do
you have that this is so? What evidence did Inspector Dodsworth
supply?
When the demands on my time allow it ... I'll add a section to the Home Page of my Website which summarizes the material given here and extends it, or gives extracts from this email and adds further comment. I have no evidence that the fallacious arguments you employ in your email were due to you. It may be that you were simply the person who transmitted the views of others at the Electoral Commission - very mistaken views, as I see it. For this reason, I won't mention your name in published material. [the reason why the person's name included in the email to the Electoral Commission isn't included here.]
You provide the information that 'Inspector Dodsworth advised you [i.e., Paul Hurt] not to contact a Green Party Councillor again because your contact was causing the councillor 'upset and distress.'
I
have pointed out that Inspector Dodsworth did no such thing. He has
never given this 'advice.' The claim is factually wrong. There is,
however, a very important aspect of this sorry business which you
appear not to have noticed. If a Green Party Councillor or MP or
other functionary were to receive comments or criticism which was
courteously expressed but which was unwelcome or very unwelcome,
perhaps because the evidence supplied was cogent or overwhelming,
then the Green Party member could contact the police, complain that
he or she (or they) had been alarmed and distressed and expect the
police to take action - by silencing the provider of the comments or
criticisms. If the police issued a statement similar to the one you
quote in your email, without even bothering to find out what the
person who had made the comments or criticism had to say, then this
would amount to suppression of legitimate comment or criticism. A
police officer is unlikely to have sufficient knowledge of the
background facts, which may well require specialist knowledge, to
give an informed response. The informed response in the vast
majority of cases would surely be no action. To do otherwise would
be to ignore the priorities of policing. The police have to deal
with many very serious problems, but this problem for the offended
Green Party Member isn't amongst them.
Again and again, Inspector Dodsworth has ignored these priorities and used up so much police time in attempts which have achieved absolutely nothing. There has been great public concern about actions of the police which restrict free expression to an intolerable extent. (I take the view that free expression can never be a completely unrestricted right.) The police have no business to restrict free expression for legitimate purposes - but you have failed to realize this. I consider that the Electoral Commission has failed to uphold precious liberties which underlie our democracy.
This is a theme which requires elaboration. I intend to provide it and to do my best to publicize it, when I can find the time. I consider that the Electoral Commission has failed to uphold essential values and has failed in matters relating to basic common sense. I intend to submit a formal complaint against the Electoral Commission. In the meantime, I suggest that you contact Inspector Dodsworth of the North West Division, South Yorkshire Police to ask if he can provide further information and further comment, information which may - or may not - be informative and enlightening. Obviously, you are at complete liberty not to contact him.
I'm alarmed that the Electoral Commission has seemingly ignored the need for responsible evidence, that it accepts the view of a member of South Yorkshire Police as seemingly incontrovertible, self-evidently true. This is a view of public discourse which is badly flawed, for many reasons.
I've already informed you
that on 17 September 2026 I contacted the Sheffield Green Party
Executive Committee to state that I wished to make a complaint
against Eamonn Ward, the Election Agent for the party, in connection
with two separate allegations he had made which I considered and
still consider to amount to defamation of character. I gave the
information that he contacted South Yorkshire Police. I made the
request to the Executive Committee that if the committee could not
deal with my complaint, that they should contact me to inform me of
a way forward. A responsible political party has to provide the
means for the electorate. the general public, to make a complaint if
necessary. Since I had received no reply to my request for quite a
long time, I contacted the individual members of the committee to
reiterate my request. I have still received no reply.
Best Wishes,
Paul Hurt
